top of page

Redesigning IA for the Gardiner Museum Website

Alongside 3 of my University of Toronto peers, this project involved analyzing the information architecture of local Toronto ceramic Gardiner Museum website in relation to its users' needs, and designing a medium fidelity prototype that improves the navigation and overall user experience of the site. 

Screen Shot 2021-03-15 at 2.38.58 PM.png
Overview

After investigating the website, collecting a content inventory, and conducting user research, we were able to identify key problem areas for users interacting with the site. 

​

The site's primary and secondary navigation schemes are a mix of both task-specific and audience-specific, resulting in feelings of confusion among users. Labels assigned to the global navigation menu were often broad and difficult to differentiate for users. 

​

To solve these problems, we focused our attention on the global navigation menu, proposing a new, audience-based organization system to better address user needs and avoid confusion. Our final product consisted of a clickable medium-fidelity prototype. 

My Role

I played a key role in conducting user research, both tree tests to identify where users run into problems on the site, and card sorts to test our envisioned organization of the system. 

​

Additionally, I was instrumental in writing our reports for each phase of the project, ensuring that they clearly and concisely articulated the information architecture problem and our proposed solution. 

​

Moreover, I worked alongside my team to construct new navigation, organization, and labelling systems and integrate them into our medium fidelity prototype. 

Articulating the IA Problem

Analyzing the site and administering a content inventory helped us to understand the context, content, and users of the system. 

​

​

Conducting tree tests with an accompanying survey on 4 participants allowed us collect data about the IA problems. 

Sketching the new IA

Testing our proposed navigation labels by executing a card sort study on 4 representative users helped us to generate new, more effective global organization, labelling, and navigation systems. 

​

​

Illustrating our new IA through a schematic diagram, and creating webpage sketches that outline user-centred scenarios and workflows helped our design come to life. 

 Medium Fidelity Prototype

Using the Balsamiq software tool to design wireframes, and linking them together to create a medium-fidelity prototype solidified our design, ensuring that it achieves its intended task of redesigning the IA of the Gardiner Museum website.  

​

​

​

Articulating the IA Problem

Content Inventory

Using OnPoint Content Auditor, and DYNO Mapper, as well as enlisting a "Noah's Ark" approach to data collection, we found that the main format types for information on the Gardiner website included text or html, images, and documents. 

Tree Test

Using Optimal Workshop, we administered a tree test on three participants which outlined tasks that were connected to three distinct user groups, in order to determine if the site's navigation schemes are actually able to direct specific audiences with specific tasks  down the right paths.

User Groups

1. A regular patron. 

​

2. A school teacher wanting to take her students.

 

3. An employer looking to do some corporate team building with his employees. 

Tasks

1. Find out what showcases/events are on for when I plan to      visit the museum.

​

2. Browse Gardiner’s collections.

 

3. Find events or activities to do with my friends, family,              colleagues, class.

Sketching the New IA

Card Sort

In order to address confusion among organization and labelling systems revealed in the tree tests, we created a closed card sort with our new, verb-based primary categories and tested it on 4 representative users to assess whether this would remedy the confusion felt among visitors of the site. 

Original Primary Navigation Labels
Screen Shot 2021-03-15 at 6.05.06 PM.png

A mixture of verb-based, noun-based, and question-based vocabulary, led to confusion among users. 

Proposed Primary Navigation Labels
Screen Shot 2021-03-15 at 5.52.45 PM.png

Our proposed primary navigation labelling system mitigates confusion by being solely verb-based. 

IA Schematic Diagram 

Considering it took the majority of participants less than three minutes to complete the card sort, with approximately half of the 33 cards being organized in the same categories consistently among all participants, and an additional 9 sorted with 75% consistency, our revised global navigation and labelling systems largely reflected the outcome of the card sort. 

Screen Shot 2021-03-15 at 6.30.46 PM.png

User Scenarios and Workflows

To sketch out the UI of our proposed changes to the Gardiner Museum website, we created a series of workflows based on what we decided were typical user scenarios. The following example shows the first few screens of our first workflow: in which a school teacher wishes to find field trip opportunities through the Gardiner website. 

Homepage
Screen Shot 2021-03-15 at 8.13.36 PM.png
Homepage - Submenu
Screen Shot 2021-03-15 at 8.13.59 PM.png
School Group Page
Screen Shot 2021-03-15 at 8.30.32 PM.png

Medium Fidelity Prototype

Based on our workflow sketches, we created a medium fidelity prototype to show, more realistically, how we were able to improve navigation and overall user experience of the Gardiner's website. Below are the wireframe versions of our sketches in the previous section. 

Homepage
Screen Shot 2021-03-15 at 8.12.10 PM.png
Homepage - Submenu
Screen Shot 2021-03-15 at 8.49.18 PM.png
School Group Page
Screen Shot 2021-03-15 at 8.51.13 PM.png

Reflection

My Role

From the outset of the project, I took an active role in articulating the problems of the IA and determining the strategies by which to solve them.

 

I conducted tree tests and surveys, as well as administered closed card sorts to determine user experiences and frustrations.

 

I then worked with my team to sketch an improved IA which used consistent verb-based labelling schemes to direct users more efficiently to the content they would be looking for.

 

Additionally, I helped to design the medium fidelity prototype, and took a leadership role in writing all three phases of the report. 

My Takeaways

Technically, this IA evaluation and design project helped me to hone my skills in using tools such as Balsamiq, Optimal Workshop, and OnePoint Content Auditor, as well as refine my report-writing abilities. 

​

Experientially, conducting user research through the methods of tree tests, surveys, and card sorts helped me to gain insights into user needs and motivations, which I will carry with me moving forward. 

​

Thanks to this IA design opportunity, my amazing team, and the research participants, all of whom I am very grateful for, I now have the knowledge and experience to be an asset when designing all things information architecture. 

To explore my other projects, click the button below. 

bottom of page